Recipes
Forgotten desserts from the 1970s that we want back
Why don't we make these anymore? They were so good! 🤤
Michael Dabu
05.29.24

Ah, the 1970s—a decade bursting with vibrant colors, groovy music, and some unforgettable desserts that have since vanished from our tables.

Today, we’re diving into a deliciously nostalgic journey through some of these treats, celebrating the flavors and memories they brought.

From creamy Pudding Pops to the boozy charm of Tequila Sunrise Cake, these desserts deserve a revival. Let’s take a sweet trip down memory lane and rediscover these forgotten culinary gems.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

Pudding Pops, introduced by Jell-O in the late ’70s, were an instant hit.

These creamy frozen treats, marketed famously by Bill Cosby, offered a rich taste that made them a household favorite.

Available in chocolate, vanilla, and swirled flavors, Pudding Pops were the perfect blend of smooth pudding in a popsicle form.

Sadly, despite their popularity, they were discontinued in the early 2000s, leaving many yearning for their return.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

Another nostalgic delight is the Magic Cookie Bar.

Originating from a 1960s Eagle Brand recipe, these bars featured a graham cracker crust topped with layers of sweetened condensed milk, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut, and nuts.

Also known as “Hello Dolly Bars” in some regions, they provided a rich, chewy bite that satisfied any sweet tooth.

However, as dessert trends shifted towards fresher options, the popularity of these decadent bars waned.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

For those with a taste for elegance, Napoleons, or Mille-feuille, were the epitome of fancy French pastries in the ’70s.

Consisting of layers of puff pastry and pastry cream, topped with a delicate glaze, Napoleons were a staple in high-end bakeries.

Their intricate, flaky layers offered a delightful crunch that paired perfectly with the smooth cream.

As lighter desserts gained favor, these luxurious treats began to fade from the spotlight, although they still hold a special place in many hearts.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

The Hummingbird Cake, with its roots in Southern hospitality, was created by Mrs. L.H. Wiggins in Greensboro, NC, and popularized by Southern Living magazine in 1978.

This cake, made with bananas, pineapple, pecans, cinnamon, and topped with cream cheese frosting, remains a beloved Southern classic.

Its moist, fruity flavor and nutty crunch make it a delightful treat, though it has slipped from mainstream fame.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

Inspired by the Watergate scandal, the Watergate Cake is another 1970s gem.

This pistachio-flavored cake, known for its distinct green hue, is made using pistachio pudding mix and club soda, often topped with a light pudding frosting and sprinkled with pecans.

Despite its unusual inspiration, the cake became a popular party dessert, loved for its unique flavor and eye-catching appearance.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

The versatile Poke Cake, promoted by Jell-O, was a ’70s sensation for its moist texture and customizable flavors.

Bakers would poke holes in a cake and fill them with jello, pudding, or sweetened condensed milk, creating vibrant streaks of flavor throughout.

This simple yet innovative dessert was a hit for its ease of preparation and endless flavor combinations.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

Butterscotch Brownies, or Blondies, provided a twist on the classic brownie.

Made with brown sugar and butterscotch chips instead of chocolate, these treats offered a chewy texture and a sweet, caramel-like flavor.

Their simplicity and deliciousness made them a favorite among home bakers, though they have since been overshadowed by their chocolatey cousins.

YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA
Source:
YouTube - Vintage Lifestyle USA

Last but not least, the Tequila Sunrise Cake brought a boozy twist to the dessert table.

Inspired by the cocktail of the same name, this cake featured orange zest, grenadine, and tequila, creating a vibrant and flavorful treat.

Its festive appearance and unique taste made it perfect for adult parties, yet it has faded into obscurity as newer, more elaborate desserts have taken their place.

From Pudding Pops to Tequila Sunrise Cake, these 1970s desserts remind us of a time when flavors were bold, and treats were as unique as the era itself.

Reviving these forgotten delights could bring a touch of nostalgia and a lot of joy to modern kitchens.

Watch the full video below.

Please SHARE this with your friends and family.

Article Sources:
To learn more read our Editorial Standards.
Advertisement