Thanksgiving
Mom shares family’s favorite pumpkin pie recipe and there’s no baking involved
Um, I think all of my Thanksgivings have just changed forever. 🥧🦃
Jessica Adler
10.27.23

Every year, as the leaves turn golden and the air grows crisp, our thoughts inevitably turn to the warmth of the holiday season.

And what’s more emblematic of Thanksgiving than the rich, creamy delight of a pumpkin pie?

What if I told you there’s a twist to this classic that’s delectable and skips the oven entirely?

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Recipesen (@recipesenn)

Stacy Gordon, our culinary guide, introduces us to this delightful variation with her no-bake pumpkin pie.

The foundation of this pie is the graham cracker crust.

Whether you’re a purist who insists on making it from scratch or someone who prefers the convenience of a store-bought version, the choice is yours.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

The magic begins with a concoction of orange juice and vanilla extract.

To this, Stacy sprinkles unflavored gelatin, emphasizing its distinction from pectin. This mixture is set aside, hinting at its crucial role later in the process.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

Next, a saucepan becomes the cauldron where flavors meld.

Heavy cream, sugar, and a pinch of table salt form the base.

But it’s the spices – cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves – that truly evoke the spirit of Thanksgiving.

As this mixture heats, bubbles whispering around the edges signal it’s time for the next step.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

In a separate bowl, sugar dances with egg yolks, creating a creamy blend.

This mixture then meets the heated cream, resulting in a custard that’s gently cooked to perfection.

A candy thermometer ensures the right consistency, but for those without, the custard’s thickened texture is the cue.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

Remember the gelatin mixture? Its moment has arrived.

Integrated into the custard, it promises to give the pie its firm, sliceable texture.

But there’s one more key player to introduce: pure pumpkin. Blended with heavy cream, it becomes a creamy, fluffy dream.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

With all elements prepared, they unite in the saucepan.

The resulting filling is a velvety fusion of flavors and texture, poured into the waiting crust.

The pie then embarks on a chilling journey, first setting for about three hours, and then firming up for another six to twenty-four.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

Stacy acknowledges the numerous steps involved in crafting this masterpiece.

Yet, the once-a-year indulgence is worth every moment spent.

The layers of flavor, the creamy texture, and the joy of creating something unique make it a rewarding endeavor.

YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam
Source:
YouTube - Stacey Gordon That's My Jam

As the pie sets in the fridge, one can’t help but anticipate the joy it’ll bring to the Thanksgiving table.

It’s a shout-out to the beauty of tradition, with a twist.

So, as Stacy would say, turn on some music, dance a little, and revel in the culinary magic of the season.

Learn how to whip up a deliciously easy no-bake pumpkin pie in Stacey’s tutorial below!

Please SHARE this with your friends and family.

Advertisement